The Frank Sinatra Essay I wrote was one of the first essays I wrote (in this class). And as I'm rereading it only one thought is going through my head: "God, this essay sucks!" Why does it suck? Honestly, I don't know yet. I have reread it only once so far and still haven't really thought of things I need to edit, but I do know that I need to edit.
For starters my intro is a piece of crap. After reading it just now, I probably wrote it first and didn't go back to it at the end of my essay. So I will probably throw away that intro and write three new ones. The next thing I notice is that I don't describe anything. Well, I describe a few parts, but still. I need to add more descriptive words, maybe some statistics or something like that. And finally, my conclusion S. U. C. K. S. Sucks. Well, everything besides the last two sentences. The last few paragraphs were extremely rushed. I am going to assume that I was writing very calmly before like the last four paragraphs, and all of a sudden I felt rushed so I just threw all my ideas down onto the paper. It could have happened differently but that is how I imagine it.
But here's the raw essay, unedited and untouched since I wrote it. Revisions will come later.
Tyler Gumina
College Composition
Hordes of people all jumping, it was the common dance. Words were spoken, only one voice was heard. Something Corporate was on the stage. Those people were the vicious fans of this fantastic band. Even with this one similarity (the love of one band), these people were anything but similar. The three biggest groups within this mass of people were the druggies, the bros and the teenage girls. Each group was there for their own reasons, with their own group of friends. I however was in one of the minority groups: just a few friends (both genders) going to a Something Corporate concert.
If you have been to a concert you would know that in each crowd there is a specific group who is more annoying than the rest. Some think that the loudest and most annoying are always apart of the biggest group. You would be surprised there, since there are quite a few druggies at each concert, yet they usually keep to themselves and just listen to the music. Next you would think to hormones and all those bros who are out at the concert to “hook up.” You would indeed find a large group who make rude remarks every once and again, but it is not the main source of annoyance. Yes, the teenage girls are the most annoying. They have this massive fascination with the lead singer of every band. They scream and swarm, trying to grab whatever they can of him. This singer in particular is Andrew McMahon.
Now, I have never met him but if I were to make any assumptions (based on the music he writes) I would say that he is a stuck-up jerk who sings about how he just wants to hook-up with girls and doesn’t care how they feel about it. More or less he seems like a pretty disrespectful guy. But in between songs it seemed like his whole personality changed. He went from a completely disrespectful guy to someone who I actually wanted to meet. And by the end of the concert I was determined to find out who he really was, and after I did that I was either going to punch him in the gut or fist bump with him. Naturally my friends wanted to get some autographs so we headed backstage before the concert ended (who would try to get backstage after the concert ended! You would have to go through a ton of insane teenage girls!). We snuck behind the rope as the show was ending and went towards their rooms. The first person we spotted was Josh Partington, the lead guitarist. Thinking that this would be the best of our luck my friends raced down the halls trying to catch him. I was going to “simply,” find the lead singer, the lead piano player, the one and only Andrew McMahon.
I’m not sure how long I spent trying to find him, but it couldn’t have been any more than a minute. My hearing was slowly improving since I wasn’t standing next to a girl who hopefully lost her voice (she was louder than you can possibly imagine). I thought I heard footsteps. Then I thought I saw a figure. However, the further back I went into the halls the worse the lighting got. My imagination was running wild, was it McMahon? What would I do when I found him – If I found him? Would I end up punching him in the gut or would I cast away my masculinity and ask him for an autograph without further thought like any of the teenage girls in the crowd? I took four more steps. As I approached the figured transformed into a six foot four white man with tattoos on his tattoos. Back stage security. He sprinted at me and slammed me into the wall directly behind me. I heard something crack.
My mind was racing. Shit, was that a rib?
Next thing I knew my feet were off the ground, and I was shaking violently. My mind couldn’t race any longer. I couldn’t concentrate on thinking. The next thing I remember was forcing myself to stand after being dropped. It was a surprisingly nice feeling. I was standing again! Although I was unsure why. Then I witnessed a sight that I never thought would happen. The giant guard was apologizing to me, and then he walked away like nothing happened.
“Hey, you alright?” an oddly familiar voice asked
I responded slowly, “Yeah, I think so.”
“So, why were you back stage anyway?” We made eye contact.
“To be honest, I don’t know anymore. I think I was looking for Andrew McMahon.” My head was throbbing.
“Why?” Although he answered quickly, it seemed genuinely curious.
“I wanted to meet him. In the songs he writes he more or less sounds like an ass. I wanted to see if he was really like that or if that was just how he portrayed himself.” Something in my head clicked. “Wait, aren’t you Andrew McMahon!?”
He nodded. “So which do you think?”
“Can I ask you some questions before I make up my mind?”
“Just don’t make it like an interview, they are no fun.”
“Umm, how do you get your ideas for songs?” If he was the person he sounded like while singing his answer would be noticeable.
“Mostly past experiences, or something I wish I did. I usually don’t try to think to hard for inspiration because then reporters will start tearing apart your life.”
“Simply enough.” He wasn’t making this up. “What was your biggest influence in your life? Did it influence your song writing?” I could see him thinking, he was trying to answer this question to the best of his ability. “Wait; don’t answer if you don’t want to. I do sound like a reporter right now.”
He laughed, “Don’t worry about it, I’d be glad to clear up any doubts my fans have of me… or potential fans at least. The answer to your question wasn’t very hard for me to think about, it was just how to word it. I was diagnosed with acute lymphoblastic leukemia before one of my concerts a while back, and I had to cancel almost half of Jack’s Mannequin Tour (the other band Andrew McMahon is in).”
“Wow, that sucks!” For some reason his leukemia diagnosis slipped my mind. “How are you now?”
“Well, I’m fine but if I sing too hard or play for excessive periods of time I have to be monitored again because I might have a relapse.” As he was talking I saw my friends in the distance.
I motioned at my friends, “My friends look like they are ready to leave, and I think I should get going. Thanks for talking to me. You’re pretty chill.”
“No problem! I’m glad I got to clear up your questions, I don’t try to look like an ass.”
“No one ever does.” The conversation dissipated as I walked towards my friends. They were all talking about how awesome Josh Partington was, but they didn’t know I got to meet Andrew McMahon. During the car ride home I was unusually quite because I was thinking one thing, I can’t believe I thought he was a jerk.
Hi Tyler,
ReplyDeleteYour introduction is clear and I know exactly what the entry is about which I am thankful for. Not everyone else did this in their first attempts at reflection. I appreciate your honest reflective voice but you've got to clean it up so that it is professional. Clean up the language as you revisit this. Remember you aren't texting a buddy but instead, this blog is a place for academic discourse and your language should reflect just that.
Use the vocabulary of the course to help you analyze your writing. Now that you've completed the course, I can't accept "I don't know why" it is weak as an answer. You need to analyze it and try to get to the heart of things. Re-read the piece several times if necessary.
For your opening reflections (this one and the others), I'd like to see several paragraphs where you really analyze your work. It has been an entire semester and you know so much more now than you did back when you wrote this piece. The REAL grade for the entire portfolio is in the reflection on the learning process and how well you can analyze your work. Be sure to use the vocabulary of our course in your explanations and to cite your own writing.
For this reflection, for example, I might have a paragraph introducing the assignment and what you like about the piece. And remember, even the roughest of pieces will have some strenghts. Look for them and analyze them specifically. When you talk about what you like, be sure to cite lines that demonstrate this. And then talk about the effect you hope that those lines will have on the reader. After that, get into a paragraph where you talk about the weak points you see. Again, use citations from the draft. And this will lead nicely into the questions you want help with.
You might consider fine-tuning this reflection before you read my comments in the posting below. There is a character limit on comments so sometimes I break them into two different comments.
I hope this helps. I probably won't say too much about your other reflections as I've said much of it here. I will look through the others and if I see something specific for you to address, I'll surely mention it but much of what I might say about reflections, I've said here.
On a side note, if you want to see some samples of how to do this. Some of your classmates have also made similar improvements and you can check them out too. Caroline does a nice job adding in some of the lines from her original draft to show why she feels how she does about her paper:
http://sugarlandd.blogspot.com/2011/01/food-paper.html
And Dan H. made nice improvements in introducing the revisions he made to the conclusions for his 7 Deadly Sins paper. He needs to clean up the spelling but the content is better that his original from a few days ago:
http://dancollegecomp.blogspot.com/2011/01/2-new-introductions.html
I hope this helps. My comments on this draft are below in the next comment box.
Ms. Basko
You don't really identify what you want feedback on clearly so I'll try to read between the lines here and go with the following:
ReplyDelete1. Introduction:
You are right, the intro wanders and doesn't really capture my interest. Perhaps you should just start with the dialogue and then reveal snip-its of where you are and how you got there sprinkled in among the dialogue.
This will also provide a balance that this piece is lacking. There is ALL that opening narration and then all that dialogue and while the paper is split half and half, somehow it isn't balanced when you read it.
2. Descriptive Writing:
There is a lot of TELLING rather than SHOWING in this piece. That is why you aren't very happy with it. There is a lot of you telling us about the types of people that go to these concerts rather than just bringing us there in the re-telling of the scene and conversation.
I think that this piece is probably a great source of discussion in your "letter to the reader." Without giving too much away, this is a great piece for you to show as an early piece that you can learn from if you spend some time really analyzing what it lacks and how you might make it better now. And then to actually do it and explain why you made the choices you made.
3. Conclusion:
Again, you tell us that you can't believe you thought he was a jerk but instead if the writing is done well, you won't have to state that dominant impression outright.
4. Anything else that jumps out at me as worthy of revision or consideration:
Once you get the draft revised, you need to take a look at cleaning up how the dialogue is punctuated and the use of dialogue tags. Sometimes it is done flawlessly and other times there are mistakes. See these two sites and read up on how to punctuate dialogue properly:
http://www.writing-world.com/fiction/dialogue.shtml
and
http://teacherweb.com/CT/ScottsRidgeMS/Jennes/punctuating.pdf
I hope this helps. Let me know if you have any questions,
Ms. Basko
Hi Again Tyler,
ReplyDeleteThere seem to be several entries missing here. Cross reference what you have done with the list on my blog and make sure that you add anything that is missing.
Ms. Basko